Notes on the 17th Amendment and States’ Rights
by Akhil Reed Amar
The Conversation
December 15th, 2005
As for repealing the Seventeenth Amendment: I once floated this idea as a thought experiment (in a footnote that appeared in The University of Chicago Law Review in 1988). [A pdf of the paper is here. See footnote 98 ---ed.]. Then I did more research into the Amendment and the issue seems far more complicated. [...]
* * *
The Discussion Continues!
by The Editors
Editorial Note
December 15th, 2005
Our meeting of the minds continues with a less structured blog chat, opening with Akhil Reed Amar’s thoughts about the repeal of the 17th Amendment . . .
* * *
Archives
- » April 2012: Where Next? The Past, Present, and Future of Classical Liberalism
- » March 2012: DNA and the Death Penalty
- » February 2012: What Is Due Process?
- » January 2012: How Drones Are Changing Warfare
- » December 2011: Will the Real John Maynard Keynes Please Stand Up?
- » November 2011: If Not Now, When? The Slow Rise of Marijuana Reform
- » October 2011: For a New Liberalism
- » September 2011: Brain, Belief, and Politics
- » August 2011: Are Men in Decline?
- » July 2011: What's Wrong with Expert Predictions
- » June 2011: Targeted Killing and the Rule of Law
- » May 2011: The Politics of Family Size
- » April 2011: There Ain't No Such Thing as Free Parking
- » March 2011: The Rise and Fall of Neoconservatism
- » February 2011: The Great Peace: Why Is Armed Conflict on the Wane?
- » January 2011: Tradition in a Modern World
- » December 2010: Property Rights in Social Democracy
- » November 2010: Following the Money: The Law and Ethics of Campaign Finance Disclosure
- » October 2010: Bourgeois Dignity
- » September 2010: Seeing Like a State: A Conversation with James C. Scott
- » August 2010: The Digital Surveillance State
- » July 2010: Darwin and Politics
- » June 2010: Discrimination and Liberty
- » April 2010: Slippery Slopes and the New Paternalism
- » March 2010: Liberty: Positive and Negative
- » February 2010: The New Sociology of Terrorism
- » January 2010: What’s Living and Dead in Ayn Rand’s Moral and Political Thought
- » December 2009: Hayek and the Common Law
- » November 2009: How the World Got Modern
- » October 2009: Inequality: Facts and Values
- » September 2009: Monetary Lessons from the Not-So-Great Depression
- » August 2009: The War on Drugs in Mexico
- » July 2009: How We Will (or Won't) Survive without Newspapers
- » June 2009: The Evolution of Religious Tolerance
- » May 2009: Ten Years of Code: A Reasessment of Lawrence Lessig’s Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace
- » April 2009: From Scratch: Libertarian Institutions and Communities
- » March 2009: Behind Bars in the Land of the Free
- » February 2009: An Appreciation of Partisanship
- » January 2009: Keep Calm and Carry On: How to Talk about Terrorism
- » December 2008: What Happened? Anatomies of the Financial Crisis
- » November 2008: When Corporations Hate Markets
- » October 2008: Is College Worth It?
- » September 2008: Responsible Drug Use
- » August 2008 Keeping Our Cool: What to Do about Global Warming
- » July 2008 After Heller: The New American Debate about Guns
- » June 2008: The Future of Copyright
- » May 2008: Can the Resource Curse Be Lifted?
- » April 2008: Can the Schools Be Fixed?
- » March 2008: Patriotism: What Is It Good For?
- » February 2008: Is Limited Government Possible?
- » January 2008: Can Marriage Survive?
- » December 2007: Do We Need Death?
- » November 2007: The IQ Conundrum
- » October 2007: Religion and Politics, Home and Abroad
- » September 2007: Is More Medicine Better?
- » August 2007: Who Needs Government? Pirates, Collapsed States, and the Possibility of Anarchy
- » July 2007: The Politics of Abundance
- » June 2007: How Global Should Government Be?
- » May 2007: Should Coercion Count? The Place of Liberty in Economic Theory
- » April 2007: Are We Happy Yet? Happiness in an Age of Abundance
- » March 2007: Libertarianism: Past and Prospects
- » February 2007: Interrogating Inequality
- » January 2007: Rethinking Health Insurance?
- » December 2006: How Much Does Culture Matter?
- » November 2006: Majority Fools? Irrationality and the Limits of Democracy
- » October 2006: Should Libertarians Vote Democrat?
- » September 2006: 9/11 Five Years After: Reassessing the Terrorist Threat and Homeland Security
- » August 2006: Mexicans in America
- » July 2006: What to Do about Iran?
- » June 2006: The Future of Work
- » May 2006: The GOP and Limited Government: Do They Have a Future Together?
- » April 2006: What Can Foreign Aid Do for the World's Poor?
- » March 2006: When Does Inequality Matter?
- » February 2006: Is "Old Europe" Doomed?
- » January 2006: Internet Liberation
- » December 2005: The Living Constitution
Discover Cato
Learn more about the Cato Institute:
Stay up-to-date daily on issues at the Cato Institute:
Cato Unbound
Editor: Jason Kuznicki
Senior Editor: Gene Healy
Cato Unbound is powered by WordPress Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).